EDR vs. MDR vs. XDR: Which Cybersecurity Solution Does Your Business Need?

Cyberattacks aren’t just becoming more frequent—they’re getting smarter. Traditional antivirus can’t stop today’s sophisticated threats. Here’s how EDR, MDR, and XDR protect your business (and which one you actually need).
Why Antivirus Alone Isn’t Enough
Gone are the days of random viruses. Today, organised cybercriminals target businesses like yours with:
- Ransomware (locking your files until you pay)
- Phishing scams (tricking employees into handing over passwords)
- Stealthy breaches (hiding in your systems for months)
The solution? Advanced threat detection like EDR, MDR, or XDR. But what’s the difference?
EDR: Your First Line of Defence
Endpoint Detection and Response (EDR) goes beyond antivirus by:
- Monitoring behaviour (not just files)
- Recording every action for forensic investigations
- Automatically isolating infected devices
The catch? EDR generates lots of alerts—many false positives. Without expert review, you might miss real threats.
Best for: Businesses with an IT team to manage alerts.
MDR: EDR + Expert Security Team
Managed Detection and Response (MDR) adds 24/7 human oversight to EDR:
- Experts analyse alerts (no more guessing)
- Faster threat response (before damage spreads)
- No need to hire costly in-house specialists
Warning: Not all MDR providers are equal. Some just forward alerts—look for ones offering actionable insights.
Best for: Businesses that want enterprise-grade security without the headache.
XDR: The All-in-One Upgrade
Extended Detection and Response (XDR) combines EDR + network-wide visibility:
- Correlates data from firewalls, emails, and cloud apps
- Fewer false alarms (smarter detection)
- Automated responses across your entire IT environment
Think of it as EDR on steroids—without the complexity (or cost) of full SIEM/SOAR systems.
Best for: Growing businesses needing complete threat visibility.
Which One Should You Choose?
image of table here
Still unsure? Ask yourself:
- Do I have staff to handle security alerts? → If no, choose MDR.
- Do I need protection beyond just devices? → If yes, go for XDR.
- Just need better antivirus? → Start with EDR.
Don’t Wait Until You’re Hacked
Need Help Deciding?
At Ashby Computers specialises in right-sized cybersecurity for SMEs. We’ll:
- Assess your risks for free
- Recommend EDR, MDR, or XDR
- Deploy it with zero disruption